Economic Releases · Today & Last 24hView Full Calendar →
Trade Review

DXY Short — 2026-09-23

Share

The objective is not to grade the P&L. It is to grade the decision.

A·Win · Average Win·RAS 93%

Charts

1 / 17

Trade Review

Trade Review — Wednesday, September 23, 2026

Session Summary

Today was a profitable adaptation day, but the most important part was not the [amount redacted]. It was recognizing that the market was delivering direction without giving the normal retracement structure your primary model needs—and finding a controlled way to participate without pretending the normal setup had occurred.

The pre-market read was already bearish. DXY had broken above its Weekly bearish FVG, VIX was recovering, and MNQ, MES, and MYM had flipped bearish intraday while remaining bullish on the 4H/Daily. The PMP specifically framed this as the first meaningful correction after Monday's expansion and warned against chasing because the move had already started before the open.

At 9:30, MNQ answered decisively.

There was virtually no conventional 1→2 retracement. Instead, the opening auction produced immediate bearish displacement. You waited rather than chasing the initial collapse, then used a lower-timeframe counter-move to enter back into the established bearish momentum.

Account: 008 Instrument: MNQ Result: +[amount redacted] Approximate initial risk: ~[amount redacted] Session return: approximately +2R


1. Pre-Market Narrative

The PMP had no need for a forced directional opinion, but the intermarket evidence had become considerably more bearish than earlier in the week.

The important pre-market conditions were:

DXY: accepted above the Weekly bearish FVG and 100.806, providing macro confirmation for the equity pullback.

VIX: recovering from roughly 14.13–14.20, with lower timeframes turning bullish while 4H/Daily remained bearish.

MNQ: 1M–1H bearish, 4H/Daily bullish, with 30,887 → 30,850 and ultimately 30,671 PDL identified as downside objectives.

MES: same intraday-bearish/HTF-bullish condition, approaching 7,810 and the former Daily bearish FVG beneath it.

So this wasn't a random short.

The bearish thesis existed before the trade.

The problem was execution: the market didn't want to give the retracement your normal model requires.


2. The Opening Displacement

This is where today's new Expansion State tracking becomes immediately useful.

MNQ entered the cash open essentially:

Ranging near the last expansion level / Last Phase 5

Then the bell rang and the state changed almost instantly:

Bearish Expansion 0→1 → No 1→2 Retracement → Expansion 2→3

That's exactly what you've entered into Airtable.

Within the first three 15-second candles, MNQ dropped approximately:

52.75 points

with essentially no meaningful retracement.

The 15-second bearish CISD extended approximately:

31,013.00 high → 30,992.75 low

The 1-minute bearish CISD extended approximately:

31,013.00 → 30,971.25

Even when price returned toward approximately the 25% level around 30,981.75, it didn't provide sustained acceptance back inside the CISD.

Then price continued lower.

That is important because today was not simply:

"Bearish CISD → entry."

It was:

Bearish CISD → immediate displacement → failure to retrace → continued expansion.

That is a different market behavior.


3. Why Not Chasing 9:30 Was Correct

This deserves emphasis.

By approximately 9:38, MNQ had already fallen about:

111.25 points from 31,013

without giving the entry structure you wanted.

It would have been incredibly easy to rationalize:

"The narrative is bearish, VIX supports it, DXY supports it, everything is bearish—just short."

But that's exactly what the PMP said not to do:

“The selloff started without me. Let it go. My opportunity begins when price reaches a location I understand and gives me a setup I can actually define.”

You followed that.

You let the first move go.

That was excellent execution discipline.


4. The Important Transition: From Setup Trading to Momentum Trading

After sweeping the pre-market low around 30,911.25, MNQ still didn't provide the larger retracement you wanted.

Eventually price established another low around:

30,860.75 at approximately 9:47

Then came the first meaningful countertrend push.

On the 15-second chart, the bullish push/CISD ran approximately:

30,865.25 → 30,894.00

And this is where the trade becomes interesting.

Instead of interpreting the bullish CISD as:

"MNQ is reversing bullish."

you treated it as:

A countertrend retracement inside an established bearish expansion.

That's the right conceptual distinction.

You weren't trading the CISD.

You were trading against the CISD and with the dominant expansion.


5. Entry

MNQ Short

Entry: approximately 30,878.75

That placed the entry around the 75% area of the countertrend range.

Size: 10 micros Initial stop: approximately 15 points Estimated initial risk: approximately [amount redacted]

Larger size was used, but dollar risk remained intentionally constrained.

That's an important distinction:

Position size increased because the stop distance was small—not because acceptable account risk increased.

That makes the structure considerably more defensible.


6. Trade Management

The management was deliberately different from how you'd handle an A+ structural setup.

You weren't targeting a huge runner.

You had larger structural objectives:

30,747.75 prior swing low

and

30,671 PDL

which was already identified in the PMP as the major downside reference.

But the trade itself was designed as:

See money, take money.

As price continued lower:

  • ▸You removed 5 contracts after the next liquidity low was taken.
  • ▸You removed another contract as the next low was taken.
  • ▸Once the trade had proven itself, the remaining position was protected at approximately break-even.
  • ▸Additional size would only be considered if another legitimate opposing retracement developed.

That is coherent with a momentum scalp.

You're essentially exchanging holding duration for initial position size, while keeping total dollar risk controlled.


7. The New Model Emerging Here

I would not merge this with your primary setup yet.

I think you are correct to treat it as a separate experimental model.

For now I'd formally call it:

Momentum Continuation Model

The basic sequence emerging from today is:

1. Direction established

There must already be meaningful directional expansion.

2. Expansion State confirms continuation

Examples:

Bearish Expansion 0→1 → No 1→2 → 2→3

rather than simply "price looks bearish."

3. Intermarket alignment

Today:

MNQ ↓ MES ↓ MYM ↓ DXY ↑ VIX ↑ / recovering

That was unusually clean relative to some recent sessions. The PMP explicitly noted that this was better multi-market confirmation than had been present in several prior sessions.

4. Do NOT chase displacement

Wait for an opposing LTF push.

5. Drop to 15s/1m

Identify the countertrend delivery.

6. Enter deep within the countertrend range

Today's approximate 75% entry is a good example.

7. Risk remains fixed

Tentatively:

[amount redacted]–[amount redacted]maximum

regardless of contract count.

8. Scale aggressively

Take liquidity → pay yourself.

9. Protect remainder

Once continuation proves itself:

BE or structural protection.

10. No expectation of home run

This is a momentum extraction model, not necessarily a swing model.

That separation is important.


8. Displacement Grade

Primary Bearish Displacement: Grade A

This is probably one of the cleanest examples you've collected.

The opening produced:

Immediate direction + velocity + range expansion + minimal overlap + liquidity consumption + continuation.

There was almost no willingness to auction back into the original bearish CISDs.

That's conviction displacement.

Countertrend Retracement: Tactical

The bullish 15-second push wasn't strong enough to change the dominant delivery.

Instead, it provided the retracement needed to enter back into the primary bearish expansion.

That gives us a useful distinction:

Grade-A primary displacement + tactical opposing displacement can create a momentum-continuation entry.

That's worth testing.


9. Expansion-State Analysis

This may actually be the most valuable data point from today's trade.

Pre-Market

Ranging (Near Last Expansion Level) Last Phase 5

Market Open

Ranging → Bearish Expansion 0–5

More specifically:

Expansion 0→1

followed by:

No 1→2 Retracement

followed by:

Expansion 2→3

This is precisely why the new Airtable fields matter.

A month from now, instead of remembering:

"That was one of those days where Nasdaq just dumped."

you'll be able to query:

What happens when the market opens near the previous Phase 5 and immediately enters a new opposing 0→1 without producing a 1→2?

And then:

How do momentum-continuation trades perform during that state?

That's actual researchable data.


10. One Thing I Would Be Careful With

There's one part of today's conclusion I would tighten.

You said, essentially:

When my normal setup isn't appearing, I'll use this.

I wouldn't make absence of your primary setup the trigger for the momentum model.

That could eventually become:

"I don't see my setup, therefore I'll find a momentum trade."

Instead:

Momentum conditions must independently qualify.

So the rule should become:

Momentum Model Eligibility

The Momentum Continuation Model is eligible only when:

Directional expansion is already established + displacement is Grade A/B+ + expansion state supports continuation + correlated markets broadly confirm + a defined LTF countertrend retracement appears.

If those aren't present:

No primary setup + no momentum setup = no trade.

That's the safeguard I'd build around this.


Rule Adherence Score — RAS

CategoryScoreAssessment
Narrative Alignment10/10Trade aligned directly with the pre-market corrective/risk-off scenario.
Setup Quality8/10Strong momentum environment, but this remains an experimental rather than fully validated model.
Entry Confirmation9/10Excellent use of the countertrend LTF push instead of chasing the initial displacement.
Risk Management9/10~[amount redacted]planned risk was controlled; larger size deserves continued monitoring while testing.
Position Sizing8/1010 micros was justified by tight risk mathematically, but the model hasn't earned full-size status yet.
Trade Management10/10Scaling into liquidity and protecting the remainder fit the trade type extremely well.
Time Discipline10/10Waiting through the initial 100+ point collapse was excellent.
Emotional Control10/10No chasing, no frustration entry, no attempt to force the primary model.
Total74/80 — 92.5%Excellent execution day.

Final Assessment

P&L: +[amount redacted] Approx. return: +2R Account: 008 Primary model trade: No Momentum-model trade: Yes

The [amount redacted]isn't what makes today significant.

Monday showed you an enormous move that never gave your setup. Tuesday exposed relative-strength differences between the indices. Today gave you another directional market that refused to provide a traditional 1→2—but this time you found a controlled method of participating after the direction had already proven itself.

And critically, you didn't respond by loosening the requirements of your existing model.

You may have identified a second model for a different expansion condition.

I would keep doing exactly what you proposed operationally: 008 only for now, [amount redacted]–[amount redacted]predefined risk, track it separately in Airtable, and don't promote it into the main PA accounts until we have enough samples to determine whether today's logic is repeatable rather than simply successful once.

The research question is now very clean:

When a new directional 0→1 produces Grade-A displacement and skips the normal 1→2 retracement, can the first meaningful LTF opposing push be systematically traded as a momentum-continuation entry into 2→3?

That is absolutely worth backtesting.

Setup Tags
DOP-BOSRanging-CHOCH-LPDL+DisplacementTactical Displacement (1m)LTFSSLGrade A - Conviction DisplacementImpulse DisplacementHTFNo NewsScalpRIPSATHMomentum Trade
Execution Quality
Chased
Emotions
CalmPatientFocusedLocked InDiscipline
Written by Cory

Cory publishes the working thesis before the session, not after — this Playbook and Trade Review are part of that same documented process. No signals, no highlight reel.

Read the full story →