DXY Long — 2026-09-22
The objective is not to grade the P&L. It is to grade the decision.
Charts
Trade Review
Trade Review — Tuesday, September 22, 2026
Session Summary
Today was a controlled losing session, but I think the more important takeaway is the growing divergence between MYM and MES/MNQ.
The pre-market plan correctly identified that after Monday's enormous expansion, the primary question was whether the indices would continue accepting near the highs or finally produce a meaningful retracement. It also specifically warned against fading the indices simply because they appeared extended while VIX remained bearish.
That framework became extremely relevant today. MES and MNQ remained comparatively strong while MYM developed sustained relative weakness. I initially interpreted MYM's weakness as a temporary divergence that could resolve by MYM catching back up with the other indices. That produced two small long attempts. Neither worked.
Importantly, I kept the losses small, did not chase the MES short that I missed, and ended the session rather than trying to manufacture a recovery.
Realized P&L provided: -[amount redacted]total
- ▸001 PA: approximately -[amount redacted]
- ▸005 PA: approximately -[amount redacted]
Expansion-State Context
This is exactly the type of day that shows why the new expansion-state fields should be useful.
Coming into the session, Monday's enormous bullish expansion meant MES and MNQ were already operating from an advanced bullish expansion state, rather than beginning a fresh 0→1. The PMP described both as consolidating near Monday's highs after MES traveled roughly 172 points and MNQ roughly 958 points.
During today's active session, however, the indices did not remain synchronized.
MES/MNQ: continued to hold comparatively high within the existing bullish delivery.
MYM: failed to participate and transitioned into sustained bearish intraday delivery.
VIX: continued bearish/downward delivery, which ordinarily supported the equity-bullish argument.
That gives us an important addition to the expansion-state study:
Expansion state should be tracked individually by instrument, because correlated instruments can occupy materially different states simultaneously.
Today's MYM behavior is a perfect example of why we discussed creating instrument-specific records rather than one generic "Index Expansion State."
Pre-Market Narrative vs. What Actually Happened
My initial thinking was reasonable.
MYM began selling while MES and MNQ were holding/pushing higher and VIX was declining. I initially looked for MYM shorts around 52,759 or 52,706, and MYM produced a bearish CISD around 52,777.
But there was no clean entry.
At the same time, the broader intermarket picture argued against blindly chasing MYM lower:
MES ↑ / holding MNQ ↑ / holding VIX ↓ MYM ↓
So I interpreted MYM as potentially experiencing a temporary relative-strength dislocation.
The problem was that the dislocation persisted.
That's the central lesson of today's session.
Trade Sequence 1 — MYM Long
Setup
MYM continued lower and eventually swept the pre-market low around 52,543.
Below price sat the Daily Open at approximately 52,456, while the higher-timeframe structure included a 1H order block beginning around 52,508.
That produced a legitimate location-based long thesis:
Pre-market liquidity sweep → 1H OB → Daily Open → potential re-alignment with MES/MNQ → bearish VIX confirmation.
Entries
I built the position gradually rather than entering full size immediately:
| Entry | Time | Price | Size |
|---|---|---|---|
| #1 | ~9:40 | 52,517 | 1 MYM |
| #2 | ~9:41 | 52,476 | 1 MYM |
| #3 | Daily Open test | 52,450 | 1 MYM |
Stop: 52,443
Maximum position: 3 micros
Account: 001 PA
Result: approximately -[amount redacted]
What I liked
This wasn't a blind attempt to catch a falling market.
There was an actual liquidity event, HTF location, Daily Open, intermarket thesis and lower-timeframe evidence. After the final entry, MYM initially pushed back toward approximately 52,485 and closed back above the Daily Open on the 15-second chart.
There was also a bullish FVG / LTF state change supporting the attempted reversal.
What failed
The critical failure was acceptance.
MYM could produce a small bullish response, but it could not actually displace away from the Daily Open/OB area.
And once the Daily Open failed, my thesis was effectively answered.
That was good trade management because I had already defined the condition:
If MYM cannot hold the Daily Open, I no longer trust the catch-up thesis.
The stop then did exactly what it was supposed to do.
Trade Sequence 2 — MYM Long
Later, MYM began stabilizing around approximately 52,377 while Trump was speaking.
Once again the intermarket picture was tempting:
VIX continued lower. MES/MNQ remained much stronger. MYM was deeply discounted relative to them.
MYM then produced a small 15-second bullish CISD.
Entries were around:
52,413 / 52,402–52,413 area
Maximum size: 2 micros
Stop: 52,377
Account: 005 PA
Result: approximately -[amount redacted]
Price initially bounced to approximately 52,429, but once again there was no meaningful displacement and MYM subsequently took the low.
The problem with Trade #2
This attempt was weaker than Trade #1.
By this point, MYM had already given us evidence that its weakness was persistent rather than momentary.
That changes the interpretation of the divergence.
Initially:
MYM weak + MES/MNQ strong + VIX weak = possible catch-up opportunity.
After MYM repeatedly refuses to catch up:
MYM weak + MES/MNQ strong + VIX weak = MYM-specific relative weakness until proven otherwise.
That's an important distinction.
The second setup still had LTF confirmation and defined risk, so it wasn't reckless. But by then, MYM itself needed to prove considerably more before another countertrend long was justified.
The Trade I Didn't Take — MES Short
This may actually be the best execution decision of the session.
MES developed a 5-minute bearish CISD with the relevant structure approximately:
Low: 7,837 Midpoint: 7,842.75 High: 7,848.50
I wanted a lower-timeframe bearish confirmation/retest for entry around approximately 7,841.
Around 10:13, MES pushed to roughly 7,845.75, produced the lower-timeframe transition, and then sold rapidly.
The entry simply moved too quickly.
I missed it.
And I didn't chase it.
That's exactly correct.
The market eventually moving where I expected does not retroactively make a late entry valid.
This directly reinforces the statement from today's PMP:
“A move I couldn't define wasn't my trade.”
Monday demonstrated that principle on a massive bullish move.
Today demonstrated it on a smaller bearish MES setup.
Same rule.
The Biggest Lesson — Relative Weakness Can Be the Signal
This is where today's review becomes particularly valuable to the study we've been doing between the three indices.
We've recently been asking:
When MES, MNQ and MYM disagree, which instrument is actually giving us the best information?
Today, MYM wasn't simply "behind."
It was weak.
There is an important progression here:
Stage 1 — Divergence appears
MYM ↓ while MES/MNQ ↑.
At this stage, catch-up remains plausible.
Stage 2 — MYM reaches bullish location
Liquidity sweep + OB + Daily Open.
Now MYM gets an opportunity to prove the catch-up thesis.
Stage 3 — MYM produces LTF bullish confirmation
Still valid.
Stage 4 — MYM fails to displace
Now the information changes.
Stage 5 — MYM loses the Daily Open and continues making lows while MES/MNQ remain stronger
At this point:
The divergence itself becomes evidence of relative weakness.
That's the part I want added to the framework.
New Rule — Catch-Up Confirmation
Do not trade an index simply because it is lagging stronger correlated indices.
For a lagging index to become a catch-up trade, require:
Liquidity event → CISD → displacement → acceptance → correlated markets remain supportive.
CISD alone isn't enough.
VIX Gave Correct Information — But Not About Which Index to Trade
There's another subtle distinction here.
The PMP had VIX bearish and specifically warned that continued VIX weakness gave little intermarket justification for aggressively fading equities.
VIX ultimately continued lower.
So the VIX read wasn't necessarily wrong.
The mistake would be interpreting:
VIX ↓ = every equity index must ↑
Instead:
VIX ↓ = broad risk environment supportive of equities
but relative strength determines where that support is actually expressing itself.
Today it expressed itself much better through MES/MNQ than MYM.
That's another reason the multi-index expansion tracking you're building in Airtable should become valuable.
Displacement Grade
The distinction between confirmation and actual displacement was especially important today.
MYM Trade #1: C+ displacement. Initial bullish reaction existed, but no sustained expansion away from the Daily Open/OB.
MYM Trade #2: C displacement. The 15-second CISD generated only a modest pop before the originating low failed.
MES missed short: A-/B+ displacement after confirmation. This was precisely why chasing it would have been dangerous—the displacement occurred faster than the planned entry could be executed.
Today's lesson:
CISD establishes the possibility of a change in delivery. Displacement proves that participants are actually repricing the market.
Risk & Execution
This is one of the strongest parts of today's session.
You were trying to solve a difficult intermarket condition, but you didn't pay heavily for being wrong.
Maximum MYM exposure was only three micros on the first attempt and two micros on the second.
Losses:
001: -[amount redacted] 005: -[amount redacted] Total: -[amount redacted]
More importantly, after missing the cleaner MES short, you didn't increase size, chase price, or attempt to force the session green.
And your closing thought matters:
The week isn't over. Small losses don't require an immediate recovery.
That's exactly the mentality that prevents a -[amount redacted]analytical mistake from becoming a four-figure emotional mistake.
Rule Adherence Score — RAS
| Category | Score | Assessment |
|---|---|---|
| Narrative Alignment | 8/10 | Intermarket thesis was logical, but MYM's persistent weakness eventually needed greater weighting. |
| Setup Quality | 7/10 | First MYM setup had strong location; second was materially weaker after the first catch-up failure. |
| Entry Confirmation | 7/10 | CISD/FVG evidence existed, but displacement/acceptance was insufficient. |
| Risk Management | 10/10 | Small size, predefined stops, very limited account damage. |
| Position Sizing | 10/10 | 1–3 micros while testing the thesis was appropriate. |
| Trade Management | 9/10 | Daily Open invalidation was respected and losses remained contained. |
| Time Discipline | 9/10 | No chase of the MES move and session ended appropriately. |
| Emotional Control | 10/10 | No revenge trading, no escalation, no attempt to force the week positive today. |
| Total | 70/80 — 87.5% | Strong rule adherence despite a losing session. |
Final Assessment
Trading result: -[amount redacted] Execution result: Strong Primary analytical error: expecting MYM to catch up rather than allowing persistent divergence to graduate into a relative-weakness signal.
I don't see today's result as evidence that the broader framework failed.
I see something more specific:
You correctly recognized the divergence but initially chose the wrong resolution of the divergence.
You thought:
MES/MNQ strong + VIX weak → MYM eventually catches up.
The market answered:
MES/MNQ strong + VIX weak + MYM repeatedly unable to rally → MYM is the weak member of the three.
That's extremely useful for the work we've already started on selecting between the three indices.
And today's new expansion-state tracking should help quantify exactly this phenomenon. Instead of recording merely “bullish equities,” we'll eventually be able to record that MES/MNQ were occupying advanced bullish expansion states while MYM had transitioned into a different delivery state.
If that pattern repeatedly precedes better trades in the weak index on bearish setups—or tells us to avoid trying to buy the laggard—we'll have actual data supporting the relative-strength framework rather than relying on visual hindsight.
Cory publishes the working thesis before the session, not after — this Playbook and Trade Review are part of that same documented process. No signals, no highlight reel.
Read the full story →